Geddit? Because Bioshock takes place underwater and a wet dream is a type of dream you can have that’s erotic in nature?
All bad punnery aside the matter at hand could not be one of more gravity. They’re making Bioshock into a movie. Or at least they’re trying to. It seems like the movie is stuck in a permanent phase of pre-production. Which isn’t necessarily a bad thing. Video games are notorious for not translating well onto film and a little extra time for mulling things over will probably serve it well. And, unlike games like Super Mario Bros. and Tekken, the original Bioshock has a concept and a story line so thrilling it’s almost hard to see how it wouldn’t work as an epic movie.
The only problem is that although it is known that a Bioshock movie is definitely happening any reliable information stops right there. Although names like Gore Verbinski and Wentworth Miller have been floating around for some time nothing has been officially confirmed. But when it comes to casting a film like Bioshock why should it be left up to the big time producers and directors?
Is a fan not entitled to the film of their choosing? No, says the man in Suburbia. It belongs to the mainstream. No, says the man in Hollywood. It belongs to Viacom. No, says the man on the Internet. It belongs to everyone. I rejected those answers. Instead I chose something different. I chose the impossible. I chose a Dream Cast. An actor that would not fear carrying an entire movie on their own, method actors who would not be bound by petty scripts, A-List Academy Award winners who would not feel constrained by their small roles and relatively little screen time.
(Note. The credit for this idea is in part due to ToplessRobot.com. This is something I wouldn’t have been prompted to think about if not for the Dream Casting Contest. Thanks for the Honorable Mention!)
Sam Rockwell as Jack Ryan
The first (and possibly most important) thing any actor that ultimately plays Jack Ryan is going to need is the ability to carry an entire film. Even after some inevitable tweaking that will be needed to make Jack’s time in Rapture a less solitary affair the main character will probably still be spending a lot of time in relative isolation. And, as anyone who’s seen Moon can confirm, Rockwell is very adept at carrying a movie that was just him and a disembodied voice. Surely conversing with the disembodied Atlas wouldn’t be much different.
In general Rockwell is a very underrated actor. For one thing he’s more than capable at playing a great range of characters and always displays a very wry (often dark) sense of humor that would be well-suited to Bioshock’s tone. Physically he makes for a good Jack. He has a very period, slightly rough look about him without sacrificing the audience’s sympathy.
Throw in a wool sweater and an all-purpose wrench and you’ve got the perfect Jack Ryan.
Liam Neeson as Atlas
Atlas is never seen but his role is immensely important when it comes to that fateful twist. Atlas should have the quality of a great mentor with more than a little righteous indignation when it comes Andrew Ryan. But the utmost important thing is that it should be the voice of someone that Jack and the audience will trust implicitly and unquestioningly. In which case, there is only one reasonable answer:
Aslan.
Neeson has even played a trusted mentor figure who ends up not only being an agent of deception but also the ultimate villain. If he could do it as R’as Al Ghul he could do it as Atlas. But in order to make the reveal all the more shocking he can’t just feel like a talking head. All those stories about his wife and family – the audience has to fall for it hook line and sinker. And humanity is something that will be easily accepted from a voice like Neeson’s.
Anjelica Huston as Bridgette Tenenbaum
Huston has some previous experience that by no means made her break her inclusion in this Dream Cast, though they do make for some interesting correlations. She’s already played Sam Rockwell’s mother in a movie and she has some experience being a Tenenbaum (though the, admittedly, the spelling is different).
But the bottom line is that Huston is fierce. Both in the Webster’s Dictionary as well as the Tyra Banks sense of the word. We’ve seen her as Morticia Addams and as the mother in The Darjeeling Limited so we know she can play a maternal figure with a bite to her.
Jeff Bridges as Andrew Ryan 
My runner up for Andrew Ryan was Stephen Colbert. Rapture seems like exactly the kind of thing he would love. Colbert as the proverbial king of Capitalism was a perfect fit.
While the Dude himself may seem like the ideological opposite of Ryan there’s no denying that Bridges has the acting chops to pull of anything. Ryan should have sure of himself swagger which, if Iron Man is any indication, he he can do.
Not to mention he’s got a great, distinctive voice. Perfect for delivering that legendary opening monologue that the filmmakers would simply have to be nuts to cut.
Daniel Day-Lewis as Frank Fontaine
Now, Mr. Day-Lewis may have turned down Lord of the Rings, deeming the project beneath him, so he may not feel too inclined to take on a video game movie. (After all, he’s got a busy schedule cobbling shoes in the obscure foothills of Ireland.) But the man appeared Nine so I think it’s safe to say that all bets are off when it comes to everybody’s favorite, extremist method actor.
But what would make Day-Lewis such a great Fontaine is that he plays such an amazing villain/mad man. And, since by the time Fontaine is revealed, he’s been built up so much – and Jack’s motivation in the third act of the story needs to be really convincing – that the portrayal has to be a real kicker.
No one chews scenery so exquisitely or so deftly as Day-Lewis. And he has two Oscars to prove it.
Michael Emerson as Sander Cohen
Emerson has made his name playing the manipulative and the utterly creepy Benjamin Linus on Lost. Watching him destroy the lives of everyone around him with that soft-spoken voice and precise delivery is like visual poetry. Indeed, it is clear that he relishes every cadence that goes into weaving a diabolical character.
So it would be interesting to see what he would do with the more verbose, flamboyant and (arguably) more unhinged.
After considering this it’s not too difficult to imagine Emerson ruling over Fort Frolic much in the same way he did with the island.
And the various Splicer cameos
Tilda Swinton
Swinton is an eerie, beautiful, and androgynous creature. One that I wouldn’t want to mess with if I saw coming at me down a darkened Rapture hallway swinging a scythe around.
The other thing about Swinton is that she has an undeniably regal bearing. One that anyone portraying some sort of former socialite turned Splicer would definitely need.
Cillian Murphy
Much like Swinton, Murphy has that eerie-but-pretty-androgynous thing going on. He’s a solid actor who can play a creepy mad man with disturbing ease.
What’s important, though, is not only can he play unnerving he can also play lethal. Don’t let that willowy frame fool you, as he’s played deadly characters very well. He might make his bread and butter playing emotionally complicated, understated character but watch that last third or so of 28 Days Later and then tell me you wouldn’t fear getting on his bad side.
Will Arnett
I know what you may be thinking. Her? Him? GOB the goofy magician from Arrested Development?
Yes.
When you’re playing a Splicer there’s a good chance you’ll spend a lot of your time acting from behind a mask. So you’ve got to have a great voice to back you up, which Will Arnett does. You don’t even have to watch the video, just listen to the audio as he reads a friggin menu.
Mark Hamill
As long as we’re on the subject of great voice acting it couldn’t hurt to have Luke Skywalker himself on hand.
The guy was the voice of the Joker in Batman: The Animated Series.
Need I say more?
No, I need not.

Meryl “Always-the-Right-Choice” Streep
Look, as long as I’m casting an imaginary movie filled with actors I love and/or admire I might as well throw Streep in there for good measure.Plus, how cool would it be to see her as a Splicer, being creepy and possibly messing with people’s shit? That’s right. Unfathomably cool. You’d never watch Mamma Mia! the same way again.
That is, assuming that if you’re the kind of person reading a blog about a horror video game turned movie, there’s a good likelihood you’re also not the kind of person who saw Mamma Mia!